Review: J. M.Â Bumsted, The Winnipeg General Strike of 1919: An Illustrated History
J. M. Bumsted, The Winnipeg General Strike of 1919: An Illustrated History, Winnipeg: Watson and Dwyer Publishing, 1994, one hundred forty pp., illus. ISBN 0-920486-40-1.
In the nineteenth century (to paraphrase Marx) world-historical impressions occurred twice, first as tragedy and then as farce. In the twentieth, they are much likely to find reincarnation as java-table books. In this case, such a fate may be appropriate. The 75th day of remembrance of the Winnipeg general strikeclearly the occasion for this volumewas an grievous public event in the city. Winnipeggers paraded, speechified, picnicked, wrote plays, produced videos, curated museum exhibits, sang, presented historical papers, and traced the route of a walking and driving tour, all to mark the anniversary. It was, after all, an event that historians have long credited with giving Winnipeg its unique semipolitical and social character. And it lives on in the citys joint memory. An accessibly-written and produced volume on the strike that will occupy the coffee tables of those touched by the commemorations in 1994 is to be welcomed.
That there is not a great deal of new(a) information near the general strike in this book need not be taken as a criticism.
Primary sources have, for the more or less part, been well mined by several generations of historians from D. C. Masters through and through Kenneth McNaught and David Bercuson. Bumsted augments the standard works with more recent studies of women, of immigrants, and of the role of the authorities in dealing with the strike. In total, this is a competent overlay of the state of research on the general strike. On the some other hand, there is little here to reflect the development of the new labour history in the past couple of decades, with its think on working-class culture and values. The general strike was deep rooted in class-based assumptions of the value of work, community and honour. While the immediate...If you demand to get a full essay, order it on our website: Orderessay
If you want to get a full essay, wisit our page: write my essay .